Hong Kong: The Citizens’ Battle for the preservation of the Rule of Law
The hundreds of thousands of citizens who marched on the streets of Hong
Kong 15 days ago demonstrated that the Liberal democratic beliefs of the people
of Hong Kong remain unchanged and strong despite Hong Kong’s transition (1997)
from British domination to Chinese
The problem that caused the protests
Hong Kong’s long and politically entrenched civil liberties seem like a
thorn in the eyes of China’s wholly politicized judicial system. The occasion
of all these persistent demonstrations was a bill that was tabled for vote in
Parliament of Hong Kong in which that specific bill allows for the issuance of
suspected criminal offences from Hong Kong ‘s jurisdiction to China.
In fact, and behind this bill lies the opening of many “doors”
that will lead sooner or later to contraction if not the abolition of the rule
of law that exists in Hong Kong.
In such cases, in addition to the criminal offences related to expulsions
of suspects to China, a legal precedent is created where this law will also
allow the expulsion of political opponents or dissidents to the Communist Party
of China (CCP), from Hong Kong to China for trial in China.
The term political rival or dissident of the CCP is blurred in its
characterization and there are many interpretations. From the fact that one
expresses itself freely until its refusal to follow specific labour rules that
affect its personality, they are the different aspects of the definition of a
So, the expulsion of a political opponent or dissident of the CCP could be
made by various false accusations and accusations or unfounded slander against
any political opponents, asking through these lies their immediate deportation in
In such a case of application of this bill, it indirectly abolishes the rule of law of Hong Kong by denying the inalienable right of the citizen to defend himself in the face of the independent civil justice.
by Thanos S. Chonthrogiannis-https://liberalglobe.com
Government stance and protests
The Republic of Hong Kong is already under parole. This is because the
Prime Minister of Hong Kong must have received Chinese approval to take over
his duties, while only half the seats in the Parliamentary house are occupied
The recent Hong Kong protesters are very similar to the protesters of the French ‘yellow vests ‘ movement. Their similarity lies
in the fact that both movements of demonstrators are fighting for the political
freedoms of their country and their participation in social welfare, which
presupposes the existence of independent political expediency of the rule of
Their differences lie that the movement of the Hong Kong protesters is fighting
for the preservation of its civil liberties and the preservation/safeguarding
of the rule of law, while the “yellow vests” movement is fighting for
its equal participation in social well-being of their country which includes a
better quality of life (low cost of living in relation to their salaries,
securing well-paid jobs, etc.) so that they and their families can start
The effects of Chinese policy on Hong Kong
But the problem in Hong Kong comes from the Chinese policy that wants to
exercise its power by applying a policy of “deciding and ordering” to
make their political opponents disappear. The situation that is gradually
shaping up in Hong Kong is a bad precedent for Taiwan, which monitors the
happenings with concern, further increasing the questioning her about any
future union with China.
Because of its size (economic, population, social, military, political,
etc.) China cannot accept that there should be an independent system of justice
on its territory other than the profoundly politicized judiciary system that
exists in the Chinese mainland.
China implements an administrative system based on an authoritarian
capitalist system which has nothing to do with communism and its results and as
applied by its followers during the 20th Century in several
countries including China. For example, in the fact that the ownership of the
means of production belongs to the people something that Communism was doing,
it does not apply in today’s China, as employment contracts are concluded between
employees and companies/employers.
What should bedone
As the trade war between the US and China continues and intensified, China’s economy will begin to present the usual problems of the world’s developed economies. More specifically:
1. Increased unemployment due to increased labour costs that will force many companies to transfer their business activities and, above all, their production to other countries at lower labour costs.
2. Increasing the individual disposable income (PPP per capita) of Chinese citizens will mean demands from the social base to the country’s administration, for increasingly better public services to citizens (e.g. health, transport, education, etc.).
3. The intensity of the trade war can increase the pace of Chinese business bankruptcies by increasing more effectively the spectrum of unemployment across the Chinese territory.
This social pressure can very easily be transformed into a social uprising since Chinese society finds that its demands are not met. Of course, any harsh
treatment of social rebellion by the Chinese government would be mishandling,
because it would give the other countries the right to impose even stricter
measures, from existing customs duties due to commercial warfare, to the
economy of China.
Tackling this ‘social unrest’ is much better achieved by granting civil
liberties to society and by the independence of the justice system by the
We would therefore suggest to the Chinese government that it should provide for and carry out an important political reform in Chinese society.
1. The various groups-members of the Communist Party of China (CCP) each representing and different “currents” of communist theory and implementation will must be transformed into autonomous and independent political parties that will claim their election by asking for the vote of Chinese citizens based on their program and always through elections from society and throughout the Chinese territory.
Essentially, the CCP ceases to exist as the only party in China and is transformed into many small and large parties competing among the citizens’ vote in the elections which will take place across the Chinese mainland.
2. The CCP principals could designate any new Chinese constitution, which should explicitly refer to the rights of citizens in every facet of their social and political life (the right to work, the right to healthcare, the right to free expression, the right to free education etc.).
3. The CCP with its current principles will now exist as a framework of principles of the new Chinese Constitution and of course not as a party which will no longer exist.
4. The elected members of the Chinese Parliament will be elected by 2/3 of the elections that will take place throughout the Chinese territory and the remaining 1/3 of members of the Chinese Parliament will be elected by ballot of state, where each party in ballot will report a list of widely recognized/eminent persons who will represent it.
The Chinese citizens will vote for their party of choice for the elections of state based on the choice of these persons.
5. The supreme administration of Chinese justice should also be elected by the people. Each supreme judge candidate for the highest positions of justice should expose his work until then to the members of the Chinese Parliament while transmitting the presentation of his work on television, radio and internet.
In this way, every Chinese citizen will have the opportunity to be informed
of the work of each candidate in order to be able to choose whom to vote in the
justice elections. 50% of the choice will be based on 2/3 of the votes of the
members of Parliament and the other 50% from the result of the elections that
will emerge throughout the Chinese territory. The result will be binding on the
Chinese President of the People’s Republic of China since he will be the one to
designate the leadership of the Supreme courts.
The results of these reforms will skyrocket global confidence in China,
thus attracting even more capital and companies into Chinese territory.
It should be understood that the political reforms should be implemented
before the pressure of ‘social steam’ and for whatever reason, in the Chinese
society because of the aforementioned problems-requirements (increase in
unemployment, high cost of living in relation to wage levels, better working
and health conditions, etc.).
Otherwise the outbreak of Chinese society will turn not only to the Chinese
government itself but also to the overall structure of the CCP.
Thanos S. Chonthrogiannis
The law of
intellectual property is prohibited in any way unlawful use/appropriation of
this article, with heavy civil and criminal penalties for the infringer.
The Liberal Globe is an independent online magazine that provides carefully selected varieties of stories. Our authoritative insight opinions, analyses, researchers are reflected in the sections which are both thematic and geographical. We do not attach ourselves to any political party. Our political agenda is liberal in the classical sense. We continue to advocate bold policies in favour of individual freedoms, even if that means we must oppose the will and the majority view, even if these positions that we express may be unpleasant and unbearable for the majority.